Real Time Analytics

Best Pacifiers For Breastfed Newborns.

Despite the raging debate, the best pacifiers for breastfed newborns can be very useful especially when your newborn proves a bit fussy.

Yes. Some moms fear that pacifiers for breastfeeding infants could bring negative results to babies but by and large, I have always found them beneficial- provided you introduce them at the right time.

Now, as part of our ongoing kids care series, we felt an urge to tackle pacifiers for breastfed infants and clear-up some of the controversies.

And just to be sure, I will also be introducing you to some of the best pacifiers for breastfed newborns.

But first, your questions:

What Is a Pacifier For Baby?

In short, pacifiers are basically nipples that your baby can suck on.

They differ from normal bottles since they’re not feeding aids at all -they are purely for soothing and comforting a fussy infant.

When To Introduce Pacifier To A Baby

To be on the safe side, you must know when to introduce a pacifier to your baby.

Note that if you introduce a pacifier for nursing babies too soon, it may cause problems.

That’s because, despite the similarity, breastfeeding and pacifiers have different sucking motions meaning your toddler may fail to learn and appreciate breastfeeding- which is a crucial part of healthy growth.

When I consulted my pediatrician friend on when to introduce pacifier, he recommended after he/she clocks 1 month.

And only if your baby has been gaining weight well and is comfortable with breastfeeding.

He advises parents to hold on if the newborn is still struggling with breastfeeding- up to the time you feel he has mastered breastfeeding.

What Is The Best Pacifier For Breastfed Babies?

The other question some of you have been asking is ‘’what is the best pacifier for breastfed babies?’’

Now, to answer that question fully, we decided to venture out and gather as much as data as possible about the best pacifiers for newborns

And having considered all the important features (more on this later), we felt that the following as some of best binkies for breastfed babies.

1.  Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier.

What makes this Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon) to stand out is its unique shape. It naturally fits your newborn mouth and will never interfere with your kid’s normal oral development.

Don’t also underrate its durability and comfort- babies look so happy when sucking it.

The other thing, it’s made of hospital-quality silicone. This means that your baby will never detect a taste or odor

This is highly advantageous because your toddler readily accepts it.


  • BPA free /Latex-free
  • Hospital-grade silicone
  • one-piece construction


  • Highly durable
  • Perfect fit
  • Easy to sterilize
  • Strong and smooth nipple
  • Excellent quality


  • They don’t have popular cute characters/cartoons


This is one of the best hospital grade pacifiers.

Made of high-end silicone, it doesn’t have a detectable taste/odor and is readily accepted by babies.

2.  WubbaNub Infant Pacifier.

Still hunting for the best infant pacifier, we also found this pretty interesting.

First, WubbaNub Infant Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon) has a cute, unique giraffe design making it hard to lose since you can easily notice it from a far if dropped or when forgotten.

Then, its material means you will find easy to clean- and it’s good that you have the option of cleaning using bare hands or a dishwasher

Still, on hygiene, its one-piece construction doesn’t have space for germs to hide since there are no cracks or joints…again meaning it remains clinically safe.


  • Nipple Made from Silicone (Soothie)
  • Latex-free
  • One-piece construction.


  • No smell/taste
  • Very soft to hold
  • Cute
  • Hard to get lost
  • Easy to clean


  • May not last


With a unique animal design, you can notice this from afar if dropped or forgotten.

And it’s very hygienic.

3.   Funny  Cute Kissable Mustache Pacifier For Babies and Toddlers.

Babies love cute characters and find them humorous.

And you can easily make him adapt to a pacifier by opting for an attractive option.

Now, this Funny Cute Kissable Mustache Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon) looks not only cute but funny…kids love the yummy lips and warmly receive their newest comical gift

Apart from that, these are Orthodontic meaning they promote natural oral growth. They are also free from toxic materials such as phthalate


  • Mustache pacifier (with kissable lips)
  • Made from natural silicone
  • BPA-free, phthalate-free & PVC-free
  • Orthodontic, unisex
  • Shield has holes


  • Very adorable
  • Easy to sterilize
  • Shield promotes natural air flow
  • Non-allergic
  • Tasteless and odorless


  • May feel heavier


Cute and comical, these are one of the most loved pacifiers by babies.

They also promote natural oral growth in your baby apart from being free from toxic materials

4.   MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic Pacifier.

Even if it may not be the very best newborn pacifier- MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon) scores highly when compared to some of the other contenders for the best pacifier for breastfed baby title.

Starting with its open shield which allows your kid to enjoy fresh air all the way to its easy-to-hold button which makes it easier to grasp for little hands…this is very well built.

I should add that it has a silky texture and kids confuse for mom’s tit and continue to suck for long.


  • Silicone made
  • open shield
  • Symmetrical orthodontic nipple (silky texture)
  • Easy hold button


  • Great with sensitive skin
  • Kids suck for longer
  • Promotes natural jaw development
  • Easy to grasp
  • Glows at night


  • Glow doesn’t last long enough


This is a very well-designed pacifier.

It has a silky texture (like mom) and is easy to grasp so your toddler will be happy to suck for long

5.   Philips Notched Newborn Soothie Pacifier.

Philips Notched Newborn Soothie Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon) can be used even when they are very young- in fact from birth up to 3 months.

And like the best pacifiers, it is uniquely shaped and comfortably fit your newborn’s mouth not forgetting that it will calm and soothe without messing up your baby’s dental development.

It is transparent, odorless and tasteless in addition to having a lovely super-smooth nipple.

And it’s one of those that you can use for many months considering that it retains its shape even after prolonged use.


  • Natural nipple shape
  • BPA-free & latex-free
  • Made from silicone
  • One piece construction


  • Easy to clean
  • Perfect size
  • Non-toxic
  • Soft nipple
  • Scent free


  • Cost more than some of the others


Due to its natural contoured nipple shape, many toddlers love this.

It’s odorless, easier to clean and very durable.

6.  RaZbaby RaZ-Buddy JollyPop Pacifier Holder.

Combining a pacifier with a toy has one major advantage:

The eventual weaning off the pacifier will be less traumatic for your child for the simple reason that your child will still retain the comfort of her doll.

And that’s where detachable pacifiers like This Razbaby Raz-Buddy Pacifier Holder (Check Price On Amazon) come in.

You will attach a pacifier to her favorite toy to calm her and when you feel that she can do with a doll, you simply separate the 2.

This one is fantastic because it’s compatible with a number of toys (animals)


  • Detachable Pacifier
  • Made from BPA free Silicone,
  • Handmade
  • Embroidered eyes(no pellets)


  • Super soft to touch
  • Very cozy
  • Cute toy
  • Getting lost is hard
  • Easy to sterilize


  • A bit lightweight


This is one of the top-ranked detachable pacifiers…

It’s comfortable and safe for your baby but its biggest strength lies in its compatibility with many toys.

7.  BabyHuggle Monkey Pacifier For Baby.

BabyHuggle Monkey Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon) is basically a squeezable plush toy connected to a soft silicone pacifier at its front.

Your baby can carry it everywhere seeing that it has a clip that you can use to attach it to a stroller, clothing, bib, baby carrier, car seat strap, blanket, sling, and even to straps

The dummy’s neck is thin so your baby will be able to close his mouth plus move his jaw freely.

Then, its heart-shaped shield is more comfortable hence your baby will smoothly transit from this dummy on to the bottle and then to the breast when it’s time to breastfeed.


  • Dummy made from cotton
  • Detachable binky
  • Pacifier made from silicone
  • BPA/Phthalates free
  • Orthodontic nipple


  • Cutest
  • Takes any pacifier
  • The toy squeaks
  • Clips to anything
  •  Machine washable


  • Slightly bulky
  • May not last


The babyhuggle monkey pacifier for baby is one of the most innovative Detachable binkies.

It has all the features to become your baby’s best friend.

8.  Soothie Pacifier- Newborn Pacifier Soothie.

The Soothie Newborn Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon) has some convenient features. For example, it doesn’t cover your baby’s nose so he won’t struggle with his breath.

Next, it detaches from its elephant dummy meaning you can wash easily and at your won convenience.

Then, because of its special design, It’s easy to locate even when its pitch dark.

And of course, it functions well even as a toy- your toddler will find the elephant very funny to play with.


  • Monkey is 90% cotton
  • Silicone material
  • Special Designed nipples
  • BPA/Phthalates free


  • Easy to detach
  • Beautiful elephant toy
  • Very soft
  • Works so well
  • Excellent quality


  • Doesn’t have a clip


This is yet another toy cum pacifier baby pal.

It’s built to calm and soothe him/her naturally and also deliver pleasure when used as a doll.

9. Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Night Pacifier

Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Night Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon) sits very well in your baby’s mouth because the nipple is almost like a bottle’s nipple.

Then It’s shorter plus stubbier as compared to some of the competing long bulbous nipples.

Plus it’s reversible making it very easy for your baby to get into his mouth

It works well for a baby who seems to struggle with pacifiers when breastfeeding.


  • Orthodontic
  • BPA-free
  • Reversible pacifier nipple
  • Options for all ages


  • Glows in the dark
  • Supports natural oral growth
  • Smoother
  • Very durable
  • Easier to use


  • Limited color options


With one of the best nipples around, this works extremely well for breastfeeding babies.

It’s safer, orthodontic, and easier to use.

10.  Fred CHILL, BABY Mustache Pacifier

With this Fred CHILL, BABY Mustache Pacifier (Check Price On Amazon), he’ll look welcoming and funny.

He should laugh seeing himself in the mirror which helps to distract.

Well, I believe it can be a wonderful gift because kids seem to love the mustache theme

Overall, its quality-molded from durable and nontoxic plastic. The nipple is made from baby-grade silicone material and is supplied with a useful storage shell.


  • Mustache design
  • Made from silicone
  • Free from PBA & toxins
  • One-piece construction


  • Hilarious pacifier
  • Fits well
  • Easier to clean
  • Durable construction
  • Very comforting


  • Can feel heavy


Thanks to its mustache theme, your baby stands out from the crown amid the humor.

Plus the nipple is a calming influence even when your toddler is feeling very stubborn.

Factors  To Consider When Buying  The Best Pacifiers For Breastfed Newborns.

So, what should you focus on when looking for the best pacifiers for breastfed newborns?

Here are the key features:

1.     Size

Your choice of the best breastfeeding pacifier should be of the correct size depending on his/her age.

Check the package for indications on size- it should say if it’s for 6 months (and under), 6-18 months or for those aged more than 18 months.

2.     The Material Used To Make The Nipple.

Most nipple like pacifier are made of silicone or latex.

Though latex is considered softer, your baby could have latex allergies, so you will need to trend carefully.

Silicone is a more popular choice since its dishwasher safe.

3.     The Shielding

A shield is a very important part of your baby’s pacifier. It is the one that stops your infant from fully sucking the pacifier into his mouth- a potential choking hazard.

Check that it’s big enough otherwise choking will remain a distinct possibility. It’s recommended that it be at least 1.5 inches.

How Pacifiers Help
  • They soothe and distract your kid during vaccinations (He will soon stop crying)
  • Recommended for flights- pacifiers are said to make him/her more comfortable when in the air (they help his ears pop)
  • Newborn pacifiers for breastfed babies may help your kid to fall asleep (No more sleepless nights)
  • They reduce sudden infant deaths according to this research
Disadvantages of Pacifiers
  • If your kid continues using a breastfeeding pacifier beyond her second birthday, there could suffer dental implications, especially poor jaw growth.

So, wean her off their nipple pacifier before their second birthday.

  • Making your baby forget his nipple shaped pacifier sometimes becomes a tough task
  • They can be unhygienic as they’re not very easy to clean

Putting It All Together

Our best pacifiers for breastfed newborns guide has tried to answer some of the common questions on these mom saviors like  when to give baby pacifier and what are the best pacifier for breastfed babies.

We also looked at the pros and cons of pacifiers and the features to look out for when buying and I now believe you are in a position to make an informed decision regarding the best pacifier for breastfed baby

So, can I take my bow?

Recent Content